Favorite Scene and Why
Posted: Sat May 09, 2009 5:24 pm
At the known risk of recycling an endless question, I'll do it, anyway. Not sure if the posters on this forum have rung in on DS. Movies and TV: what are your top favorite scenes, and exactly what about these scenes put them in your "Oscar/Emmy" list?
I'll go first; my top 10:
1. Tarzan's Hidden Jungle (no surprise) - great actress - perhaps the best ever in such a scene, good 10 minute build-up to the plunge, good struggling, corny but great pull-out (how come Vera Miles has curls in her hair some of the time, and straight blonde hair in most of the shots? Had to be filmed twice ).
2. Valley of Mystery (ditto) - also good actress, nice dress, nice struggle with arms in and out, excellent slow descent from chest to neck deep - arms in, decent if bumbling rescue scene (no way is that a real vine, all neatly tied like a Boy Scout project; also spliced from two filming takes).
3. All My Children - because of the extended conversation with her shoulder deep, good rescue sequence, too bad she falls on her butt rather than sinking in slowly.
4. Shelby Woo - award for best quicksand, too short and edited, I like how she pulls herself out (great!), I knew the actress was much older than her part.
5. Rifleman - yes, she's too young (hope just this mention is not out of bounds, here), but it is still a good sequence, good quicksand, good initial small submergence and slow sink, actress does convincing job of fear, terror - bumbling rescue mars it a bit.
6. Dukes of Hazzard (Daisy) - need I say more? actress, outfit, quicksand is OK, good pullout sequence with her being pulled sideways through what is somewhat convincingly thick mud, too bad it is done way too quickly (no pun intended).
7. Flying Nun - too short and edited, but Sally Fields is cute and the white habit and dark muck are good counterpoint.
8. Amuck - the perfect scene, extended sink, actress reactions are all just right, but my copies of the video are so blurred it is hard to appreciate.
9. Xena - bad dry quicksand, but the actresses are too good to ignore - any scene where the heroine pulls herself out rocks.
10. Hercules TV - quicksand too dry but still OK movement, great buxom actress, good extended pullout (even the obligatory rope-break), too bad it starts at such a deep submergence - ditch the boy!
- jack c
Edit #1 - By the way, I am lmthj on the Deep Sinking Forum, so I didn't plagiarize the lmthj list from DS - I merely paraphrased it here. It is my list both places - thanks.
I'll go first; my top 10:
1. Tarzan's Hidden Jungle (no surprise) - great actress - perhaps the best ever in such a scene, good 10 minute build-up to the plunge, good struggling, corny but great pull-out (how come Vera Miles has curls in her hair some of the time, and straight blonde hair in most of the shots? Had to be filmed twice ).
2. Valley of Mystery (ditto) - also good actress, nice dress, nice struggle with arms in and out, excellent slow descent from chest to neck deep - arms in, decent if bumbling rescue scene (no way is that a real vine, all neatly tied like a Boy Scout project; also spliced from two filming takes).
3. All My Children - because of the extended conversation with her shoulder deep, good rescue sequence, too bad she falls on her butt rather than sinking in slowly.
4. Shelby Woo - award for best quicksand, too short and edited, I like how she pulls herself out (great!), I knew the actress was much older than her part.
5. Rifleman - yes, she's too young (hope just this mention is not out of bounds, here), but it is still a good sequence, good quicksand, good initial small submergence and slow sink, actress does convincing job of fear, terror - bumbling rescue mars it a bit.
6. Dukes of Hazzard (Daisy) - need I say more? actress, outfit, quicksand is OK, good pullout sequence with her being pulled sideways through what is somewhat convincingly thick mud, too bad it is done way too quickly (no pun intended).
7. Flying Nun - too short and edited, but Sally Fields is cute and the white habit and dark muck are good counterpoint.
8. Amuck - the perfect scene, extended sink, actress reactions are all just right, but my copies of the video are so blurred it is hard to appreciate.
9. Xena - bad dry quicksand, but the actresses are too good to ignore - any scene where the heroine pulls herself out rocks.
10. Hercules TV - quicksand too dry but still OK movement, great buxom actress, good extended pullout (even the obligatory rope-break), too bad it starts at such a deep submergence - ditch the boy!
- jack c
Edit #1 - By the way, I am lmthj on the Deep Sinking Forum, so I didn't plagiarize the lmthj list from DS - I merely paraphrased it here. It is my list both places - thanks.